$11m. Rafale deal, RahulG, Mme TAK, Colombian Kattalis - R. Vijayaraghavan
Though
there are no fingers pointed at anyone in particular in the $11 million
Rafale jet fighter deal, it certainly has strange connections and cross
connections
There have been allegations that pressure from the highest political
level, and possibly a huge under-the-table payment, dictated India's
decision to plump for the Rafale jet fighter made by Dassault of France.
The order is for 126 fighter-jets worth an immense $11 billion. These
jets are meant to replace the country's ageing fleet of MiG 21s, which
make up one-third of the Air force's jet fighters.
Collateral evidence has emerged, through research by Subramanian
Swamy and our searches on Google and other internet sites, that blood
relations and close friendships at the top political level probably
tilted the scales in favour of the Rafale. There is as yet no evidence
that Dassault paid a huge bribe to India's first family, though the
possibility cannot be ruled out, given the current milieu in India.
It is a tangled skein and one end of the thread begins with T
Anantha Krishnan, popularly called TAK. He is the son of a Sri Lankan
Tamil immigrant, who was an indentured plantation worker.TAK was
reputedly close to K Padbanabhan, money manager of the LTTE, who is now
in jail in Sri Lanka.
TAK has no further role in this tale, except that his wife is
Latchoumie Marie Helene, born to a white French father who belongs one
of the ancient families of France and a Tamil mother. She is popularly
known as Mme TAK and Latchoumie is probably the Frenchified version of
Lakshmi, a common Tamil name...
Mme TAK, is the owner of La Fantaisie, a very big art gallery and
auction house in Paris, which can be described as the Christie's of
France. Carla Bruni, the Italian wife of Nicholas Sarkozy who was the
French president when the Rafale deal was inked, is a partner in this
venture for the past two years.
Mme TAK is also owner of a sophisticated music recording house in
Paris. Carla, who is also a pop singer, uses Mme TAK's studios for
registering and issuing her albums.
She counts among her good
friends Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi and Sonia's sisters who frequently
visit her in France and stay in her chateau. Rahul Gandhi stayed with
her when he went to France in early 2012.
Mme TAK owns vineyards in northern Colombia with jointly with rich
Colombian families called Bettancourt and Katalli. Rahul Gandhi's former
live in girl-friend Veronique is connected to the Kattallis.
Now comes the interesting point. Mme TAK is one of the shareholders of Dassault.
Carla Bruni is Italian born. She is related by marriage to Sonia
Gandhi: Carla is a cousin of Sonia Gandhi's sister's daughter-in-law.
Discussions
are still going on between India's defence ministry and Dassault,
particularly on the 'offset' condition under which around 50% of the
aircraft will have to be built by Indian manufacturers.
A couple of months ago, Moneylife wrote on the choice of the Rafale. The headline of the story was
"Look out, Mr Antony, Little Brother is watching you".
This is Little Brother signing off, till the next instalment.
R
Vijayaraghavan has been a professional journalist for more than four
decades, specialising in finance, business and politics. He conceived
and helped to launch Business Line, the financial daily of The Hindu
group. He can be contacted at
rvij10@yahoo.com).
http://www.moneylife.in/article/the-curious-rafale-deal/26217.htmlOne of the biggest-ever defence contract for 126 fighter jets
worth a huge $11 billion will be closely watched for any signs of
corruption in the deal. Mr Antony and Dr Manmohan Singh and Sonia Gandhi
better watch out as at the first sign of corruption, the whistles will
be out and blowing loudly across the land
India is finalising one of the country’s biggest-ever defence
contracts. The order is for 126 fighter jets worth an immense $11
billion. These jets are meant to replace the country’s ageing fleet of
MiG 21s, which make up one-third of the Indian Air Force’s jet fighters
which have been crashing regularly for no other reason but that they are
aged.
Originally six companies and consortia put in bids for the tenders
which were announced in early 2011. The six were: Dassault of France
which is offering its Rafale jet fighter; a consortium of the
pan-European EADS, BAE Systems of the UK and Finmeccania of Italy. This
grouping is offering the plane called the Eurofighter Typhoon; Lockheed
Martin of the US bid with its F-16 fighter aircraft; Boeing of the US
which placed on the table its bid to supply the F-18 Super Hornet; Saab
of Sweden offered its Gripen fighter and Russia which wanted to sell its
MiG 35.
India made a shortlist of two in April this year: Dassault’s Rafale
and the Eurofighter Typhoon of the pan-European consortium. The bids for
the shortlisted two fighters were opened last Friday. No details have
been released as to what the bids offer.
The defence ministry, it is understood, will evaluate the bids on
the basis of three criteria: The cost of acquisition and what is known
as the “life-cycle cost of the aircraft” and “military offset
considerations.” The last criterion covers the extent of technology
transfer and the investment the bidders will put into the country’s
defence industries if they are chosen.
According to informed sources, the two US companies lost out because
they did not offer their latest and technologically most advanced jet
fighters. The controls imposed by the US government on transfer of
technology to India also came in the way of these two companies.
India’s jet fighter order is stated to be of vital importance to the
shortlisted bidders. Both are looking for export markets since defence
budgets are shrinking in the developed world.
The Eurofighter
Typhoon has four main customers: the UK, Germany, Spain and Italy.
Austria and Saudi Arabia also operate the jet. But military sources say
there are no other firm export orders for the Typhoon at present.
The stakes are said to be higher for the Dassault. The Rafale came
out as France’s decision to pull out of the pan-European project with
Germany, the UK, Spain and Italy to share the development costs of a new
fighter that ultimately became the Typhoon. The Rafale has no customers
outside France. Dassault is hoping to sell the Rafale to Brazil and the
United Arab Emirates.
All this is fine and till now everything is going by the book. But
the future could be worrying. The financial well-being of both the
shortlisted bidders depends heavily on securing our order. Therefore,
the cynic would be justified in warning that there could be ‘pressures’ a
la Bofors on the politicians, bureaucrats and Air Force bigwigs
deciding the deal.
And then, $11 billion is a huge, humongous amount of money. When
such money changes hands, it is but human nature that some of it will
adhere to sticky fingers and become unstuck in a ‘safe’ banking haven in
Switzerland or the Cayman Islands or Bermuda.
Luckily, perhaps, we have a supposed incorruptible in AK Antony, the
defence minister. And we hope that he will continue to maintain his
reputation while dealing with this order.
Still, we at Moneylife and in the huge Indian press as well feel constrained to issue a warning.
We will be watching this deal very closely. We assure Mr Antony and
Dr Manmohan Singh and Sonia Gandhi that we will be able to sniff out the
first odour of corruption in this deal. The press has its sources of
information.
So the trio had better take care. At the first sign of corruption, the whistles will be out and blowing loudly across the land.
(R
Vijayaraghavan has been a professional journalist for more than four
decades, specialising in finance, business and politics. He conceived
and helped to launch Business Line, the financial daily of The Hindu
group. He can be contacted at
rvij10@yahoo.com).
http://www.moneylife.in/article/look-out-mr-antony-little-brother-is-watching-you/21250.html